Double Standards in Leadership: Rules for You, Not for Me

How Leader Hypocrisy Destroys Trust and Culture

Your one job as a leader is to build a high-performing culture. But nothing sabotages that mission faster than a single, toxic dynamic: The double standard.

You set clear, strict rules for punctuality, communication response times, or expense reporting. You demand accountability and discipline from your team. Yet, when the rules conflict with your schedule or preference, you are the first to bend them. You show up late. You ignore the email chain. You approve your own expense exception because "it's different at my level."

The moment your team registers this inconsistency, the damage is immediate. You haven't just broken a rule; you've broken the foundation of trust that holds your team together.

The Hidden Cost of Double Standards

This double standard, this word-deed inconsistency, is the fastest way to hemorrhage credibility. Whether the transgression is small (a leader who insists everyone be in the office by 9:00 AM but strolls in at 9:30 AM) or big (a leader who preaches transparency but withholds key organizational information), the hidden cost is massive and organizational-wide.

When leaders operate under "rules for thee, not for me," the following becomes inevitable:

• Trust Dies: If you do not follow your own rules, why should anyone believe your commitment to the company mission, the team's goals, or their professional development? Leadership becomes an empty, transactional title.

• Voice Disappears: People stop speaking up. If integrity is clearly negotiable at the top, employees internalize that their honest feedback, ideas, or concerns about a project are not genuinely valued. Cynicism spreads.

• Engagement Plummets: Employees shift from leaning into their work to rolling their eyes. They stop investing their discretionary effort, knowing the rules are a façade.

Trust takes years to build, but hypocrisy can kill it in seconds.

Why Even Good Leaders Become Hypocrites

Most leaders who fall into this trap do not think of themselves as hypocrites. They justify the inconsistency with a series of self-serving rationalizations:

1. "My work is more urgent." (The rules are for low-priority tasks; my tasks are strategic emergencies.)

2. "I'm too busy." (The team has time for process; I don't.)

3. "The rules don’t apply at my level." (My title is the permission slip.)

Here is the hard truth: Your team notices. They always notice. Your rank excuses do not make the inconsistency disappear; they simply amplify the message that your personal convenience outweighs organizational integrity. When that message lands, your credibility is gone.

The Path Back to Integrity: Three Leader Commitments

The good news is that this is fixable, but it requires a difficult, conscious commitment to consistency, starting immediately with yourself. You must close the gap between what you say and what you do.

1. The Mirror Test (Before You Enforce)

Before you send the email, call the meeting, or enforce a policy, stop and perform the Mirror Test. Ask yourself: "Am I modeling this behavior right now?"

If you are about to talk about the importance of responsiveness, look at your own inbox. If you are about to mandate punctuality, check the clock. If you cannot honestly say you model the rule 90% of the time, you have two options: change your behavior first, or change the rule.

2. Own Your Slips (The Power of Confession)

Perfection is not required; consistency is. When you inevitably slip up, use it as an opportunity to reinforce the standard, not undermine it.

If you are late for a meeting you mandated be on time, say it out loud: “I expect us to be on time, and I didn’t meet that standard today. That’s on me.” This short sentence shows humility, acknowledges the collective standard, and prevents the team from justifying their own future slips with your behavior.

3. Lead the Change (Accountability Flows Uphill)

If a rule is genuinely outdated, cumbersome, or unsuited for a specific role (including yours), do not break it privately. Instead, lead the systemic change publicly.

If your team needs the freedom to start later due to global scheduling, don't secretly grant yourself the exemption; announce the new, more flexible policy for everyone. Accountability flows downhill, but it must be established and modeled at the top.

The Bottom Line

Your team doesn't need you to be perfect. They need you to be consistent. When you, the leader, live by the same rules you set for others, trust grows, commitment deepens, and your leadership is perceived as legitimate.

If you want your team to listen, speak up, and follow, the process is simple: Start by walking your own talk.

---

Visit us at savvyhrpartner.com and follow us on social media @‌savvyhrpartner for expert tips, resources, and solutions to support your business and your people. Let’s bring savvy thinking to your people strategy!